The natural history of the Nutella donut

Nutella donuts

Nutella donuts – by the truckload. Photo: Matt Holden

Ground Zero for Melbourne’s Nutella donut boom was a quiet northern suburbs street that runs off Sydney Road opposite Fawkner Cemetery. Among the brick veneer and weatherboard bungalows built by migrants from Italy and Greece in the 1960s and 1970s is a row of shops, empty-looking except for the milk bar in the middle, Jimmy’s Place. It was here, in June 2015, that sales of donuts filled with Nutella went through the roof: within three weeks of placing an order for 75 with a local baker and advertising the donuts on their Facebook page, Jimmy’s was selling 1000 donuts a day, with queues stretching out the door, customers sending couriers across town, and someone messaging a request from Texas for donuts to be frozen and flown there (“We wouldn’t do that,” says Jimmy Othman. “They have to be fresh.”)

Several months later the donuts are still selling in big numbers, though people call ahead – the phone rings twice in a few minutes with inquiries – and bulk orders come from local companies such as Ford and Holden; an architect in Melbourne city wanted 300 not so long ago.

The donuts are delivered at 6.30 each morning, and Jimmy Othman and his wife, Zena Samia, are up packing them into boxes for the orders.

Jimmy, an engineer by training, met Zena in Lebanon, where she was on holidays. He has blue eyes and fair olive skin that makes you think he’s more of a central Italian more than a Lebanese. He’s open and friendly, but the only things he is giving away are a bottle of water from the fridge (“Please. It’s our custom”) and one of the Nutella donuts (“I’ll warm it up for you. It’s better that way.”)

He prefers not to publicise how many they’re selling now: “Numbers are very dangerous,” he says, nodding towards the street outside. When you multiply the numbers by $3, you see why: it’s still a working-class neighbourhood where not everyone is working. That’s a lot of donuts, though not as many as the 3000 he says they sold in one day at the height of Melbourne’s Nutella donut bubble in early 2015.

“It’s like a dream…” Jimmy says, and you picture donut-money raining gently on the brown tile roofs of the suburb.

The donuts come from an Italian baker in neighbouring Thomastown, a similar brick-veneer dormitory suburb with a big population of migrants from the Mediterranean. “He’s already very busy, so he doesn’t want me to say who he is,” Jimmy adds. Not even to talk off the record about his donuts? “No. Sorry. He’s very busy baking bread.”

Jimmy and Zena lived in Dubai for five years until she got homesick for Australia. He couldn’t find an engineering job in Melbourne, so they took over the deli from Zena’s parents (she grew up in the house behind the shop). Then the donut thing happened. “It’s like a dream…” Jimmy says, and you picture donut-money raining gently on the brown tile roofs of the suburb.

The donuts are displayed in a perspex case on the counter, just a couple of dozen: Nutella, custard, jam. They’re big, the dough is soft and pillowy, and they’re well dusted with icing sugar. The Nutella – thanks to the microwave – is warm and runny, and they are impossible to eat politely while Jimmy watches.

Jimmy puts the craze down to word of mouth – especially on Facebook, where Jimmy’s Place now has 5300 likes.“People tell other people and they want to try them,” he says. The page features photos of donuts, a weekly update – “Donuts ready now!!!” – and nothing much else.

“I know my food, and these donuts are good. Fresh ingredients, no preservatives. When I get the first delivery in the morning the smell is very tempting. I can’t resist,” Jimmy says.

Nutella donuts

Mick’s Place in Thomastown – home of the Donutella. Photo: Matt Holden

A few kilometres north, across the ring road that divides Melbourne’s inner and outer northern suburbs, is Mick’s Place in Thomastown. Mick Solomon is Jimmy’s brother-in-law, and the same week that Fairfax Media’s Good Food website broke the story of the donut craze at Jimmy’s, the local newspaper in Thomastown reported that Mick’s was selling up to 4000 donutellas (as he calls them) a day, including 4300 one Sunday.

Mick’s Place is a low brick building painted fire-engine red that sits on its own suburban corner surrounded by car parking spaces. The coffee comes in takeaway cups even if you’re having it at one of the umbrella-shaded tables out front. A young Lebanese-Australian guy pulls up in a silver BMW and gives himself a spritz of cologne before he goes inside (the counter girl, a family friend of Mick’s, is cute). One shelf displays shisha pipes – including several modelled on an AK-47 assault rifle; you picture Lebanese-Australian youth laughing as they take hits of fruit-flavoured smoke from the barrel of the assault rifle like stoner Vietnam GIs.

The donuts are in a perspex display case here, too, though there are several dozen, taking up most of the counter, and in more flavours than at Jimmy’s.

Mick’s not in – he’s too busy, says the counter girl with an enigmatic smile. She serves the espresso in a takeaway cup, and the donut is similar to Jimmy’s: soft dough, loads of icing sugar, a mouth-clogging dose of Nutella inside.

Around the time that Melbourne’s newspapers were reporting on Jimmy’s and Mick’s donut explosion, signs appeared at high-street bakeries and ordinary cafes all over town: WE HAVE NUTELLA DONUTS. You saw them outside Vietnamese hot bread shops stacked in perspex display boxes, and at suburban cafes that doubled as feral tattoo parlours. An anonymous cafe in Glenhuntly Road, Elsternwick – a south-side neighbourhood with a big Jewish population that’s famous for its bagel shops –had a sign and a tray full in the coffee hatch: they came, said the young barista, from a bakery in Derrimut, way out in the badlands of Melbourne’s industrial western suburbs. Cafe Tre Fontane, a tiny Italian-Australian espresso bar in Ivanhoe, a green middle suburb that’s home to one of Melbourne’s most desirable private schools, was making their own in-house. The story was repeated across Melbourne: NUTELLA DONUTS HERE.

Mick’s donuts came from Il Forno Ciabattaria, a bakery in the quiet back streets of Reservoir. Reservoir (you say it “reservaw” if you’re a real northsider) is another flatland suburb full of orange brick bungalows built by postwar migrants; many feature high brick walls surmounted by eagles (people from the Abruzzo) or fake Corinthian columns.

“Mick was selling 3000 a day,” confirms Carlo Cappello, co-owner of Il Forno. “Not all from here. I don’t know if he was making his own or what.”

What about Jimmy’s? Where do his come from? “I think he was getting some from Mick’s,” he says. He is reluctant to speculate. There’s an edge, though he won’t elaborate.

Il Forno is no longer supplying Mick’s Place. “That’s business. Things happen,” is the only explanation Carlo Cappello offers. “I don’t want to say that people copied us. Let’s just say we are the originals. It started from here.”

As he talks a truck arrives to pick up a stack of donut crates – 500 in all, heading for a food truck.

Il Forno has been making the Nutella donuts for at least four years, he says. Capello’s business partner saw bomboloni filled with Nutella on a trip to Italy, and thought they should give them a go.

“They took off in April or May.” It was Facebook and Instagram that did it: “People got on board, there was a bit of a frenzy. Something new, something different,” he says.

“If you walked in here on a Saturday there was a line out the door. We were piping them while people waited and selling them still warm.”

The appeal is “all in the bun. The process, the ingredients. All natural,” he says. His donuts are made from simple ingredients: “flour, water and that” – he’s a businessman, not a baker. They get a quick fry, and then the Nutella is piped in by a machine. The finishing splodge on top is added by hand. At the height of the craze, he had two workers adding splodges all day.

“When you look at the amount of Nutella, it’s pretty good value,” says Carlo Cappello.

In August 2015 Carlo Cappello even claimed responsibility for an Australia-wide shortage of Nutella, telling one local newspaper that he was going through 600 kilos a week, exhausting the country’s stock of caterers-size 3-kilogram tubs and sparking a scramble for the smaller domestic jars.

“I still use about half a tonne a week,” he says. “Five hundred kilos. You can get it, but you have to get in early.”

The frenzy has eased: “It’s tapered off. It’s steady, but not as crazy as it was. There’s still a queue on Sundays.”

Also on display at Il Forno are donuts filled with the more traditional Italian baker’s custard, crema pasticcera. They cost $4.50, while the Nutellas are just $3. “When you look at the amount of Nutella, it’s pretty good value,” says Carlo Cappello.

Nutella donuts

Il Forno Ciabattaria ships Nutella donuts out by the crate. Photo: Matt Holden

The Nutella donut is the 21st-century offspring of custard-filled bomboloni that came from places like Pasticceria San Giusto, which stood for half a century in Lygon Street, East Brunswick, an old working-class neighbourhood in Melbourne’s inner north full of tiny terrace houses that Italian migrants colonised while they were earning the money to build their brick palazzi further north. San Giusto was a little bakery with a wood-panelled front room and a counter where a couple of dozen pastries were displayed at a time: cornetto alla marmellata and bomboloni filled with vanilla custard were the best.

Orlando Artavilla, who now owns Candied Bakery in Spotswood with his partner, Toula Ploumidis, bought San Giusto in 2004 and converted it into bakery cafe Sugardough as the neighbourhood was gentrifying.

“We took over the bomboloni recipe,” he says. “But we did them with Nutella. We also did cornetti with Nutella” – way back in 2004.

The San Giusto bomboloni were smaller and denser than today’s northern suburbs donutellas, but they were still a quick-rise dough. “There was also the yellow colouring in them that lots of Italian bakers used,” says Ortavilla. “We scaled that back a bit.”

Soon, he says, “We thought, Why are we doubling up on the Nutella in the donuts and the croissants?” They switched to chocolate ganache for the bomboloni.

Today Sugardough’s bomboloni have a dense, almost bread-like crumb compared to the lighter, spongier donutellas. They’re still filled with chocolate ganache, still have a little of the yellow colour and that sort-of-vanilla aroma of Italian pastries, and they cost just $3.20 a piece. Orlando Artavilla also did a Nutella donut at Candied Bakery when they first opened, and now occasionally does a Valrhona chocolate custard. Spotswood is another former working-class neighbourhood that’s gentrifying fast.

Melbourne’s donuts can be sorted by class, culture and geography. The donutella rules in the brick veneer flatlands of the not-so-Anglo working-class north. The light, airy donuts with cloying doses of chocolate-and-hazelnut spread have a very straightforward appeal: “Look how big that thing is!” “Look how much Nutella is in there!” “Only $3!”

At bakeries that take a more artisanal approach, such as Tivoli Road Bakery in South Yarra, a wealthy neighbourhood on the south side of the Yarra River, which divides Melbourne neatly in two, the bomboloni-style donuts are smaller than the northside donutellas – an orange to their grapefruit – and the dough is a denser, slow-rise type.

Tivoli’s English owner and pastry cook Michael James says it takes nearly three days to make his donuts, including 24 hours for the dough to ferment and another night for it to prove. Early each morning the dough is cut and shaped by hand and the donuts fried 16 or 18 at a time at 180C, drained and rolled in sugar.

The filling is piped in by hand. James uses a traditional creme patissiere, similar to Italian crema pasticcera: “It’s basically a custard of milk, eggs, sugar and plain flour, with chocolate stirred in at the end.” That makes a much lighter, creamier filling than Nutella; as Carlo Cappello from Il Forno told the newspapers: “When you bite into Nutella you don’t want to be able to speak, it should clog up your mouth.”

The dough is made with flour, water and yeast plus ferment (leftover dough from other bread and pastry-making). The long fermentation and overnight proving give Tivoli’s and similar donuts “much more flavour and a softer, spongier crumb,” says James.

The Tivoli donuts are $4 each – about par compared with similar donuts from other artisan bakers such as Yarraville’s Cobb Lane, Candied Bakery or even the hipster donut sensation Short Stop in Melbourne city. James sells 100 on a weekday, and up to 300 on Sundays.

So to sell 3000 donuts in a day at a suburban milk bar really is something almost unbelievable: that’s more than 200 an hour for 14 hours, or three-and-a-half a minute. It barely sounds possible. People must have been carting them off by the dozen.

Nutella donuts

Mick’s graffiti wal. Photo: Matt Holden

And in fact, back at Mick’s Place, there’s a stack of boxes that would hold a dozen donuts, all labelled “Mick’s Donuts” with home-printed stickers bearing a caricature of Mick, a big, dark-looking guy. But there’s no sign of Mick.

The cute girl is at the counter, still smiling enigmatically, looking like she hasn’t moved in a week. “I gave your number to his wife,” she says. He still hasn’t called. “Mick just drops in whenever. He’s pretty busy. He’s got his own factory now. Up Sydney Road somewhere.”

The counter is stacked with donuts in half-a-dozen flavours – Nutella, salted caramel, cookies and cream. It must be all that Mick’s Place sells. ‘“Pretty much…” She nods to the coffee machine. “And cigarettes.”

On the wall outside local kids have graffitied the bricks with Sharpies: “Khalil was here … yummy donuts!”; “Khoder Mick’s nephew”; “Yeaboi #micksplace.”

Mick also has loads of fans online. His Facebook page has more than 20,000 likes. He recently ran a competition with a prize of free donuts for a year – to enter, you had to like the page and follow Mick’s on Instagram (he has 6400 followers). In the end he gave away two prizes of a year’s supply of donuts.

Back at Jimmy’s Place, Jimmy Othman still isn’t giving anything away. “Maybe Mick doesn’t want to talk; maybe he’s too busy.”

Could your wife maybe call him? “No. We don’t interfere. I am happy to help you for myself … Mick is wholesaling now, so he’s very busy.”

Where’s the factory? “Coolaroo; Campbellfield. You know it? Please – take some water from the fridge.”

A week later Mick finally calls and makes a time to talk. When I arrive, he comes out of the back room behind the shop, where he’s been sleeping, and you get the feeling he has been there the whole time – something in the counter girl’s smile, covering for him.

He is a big guy with a gruff voice and the Australian accent that betrays him as Melbourne Lebanese. He takes a seat under the umbrellas out front. His gold iPhone has the trademark cracked screen. He talks in a low whisper, fast and hard to hear.

So how did he go from corner store to donut king? “I wouldn’t say donut king,” he says.

I switched the jam for Nutella myself. We just piped it on top – we weren’t actually injecting them.

“I was selling just a couple a day. I switched the jam for Nutella myself. We just piped it on top – we weren’t actually injecting them.

“One of my customers asked for one and I said, ‘No, these are mine.’ He said, ‘Go on, give us one.’ I did. He said, ‘Oh, these are beautiful.’”

“Customers started asking for them – give me two, six, eight, 12. Then one particular day all these cars just rocked up out of the blue. They said, Is there a bakery here? I said no and they all took off without buying anything.”

One of them came back: Mick’s was the only shop in the area. “There’s no bakery here sweetheart,” said Mick. Are they Nutella donuts, she asked. Yes. She said, “Can I buy all of them – there were four left – and can I place an order for tomorrow.” She wanted a dozen.

“I thought someone was playing a prank,” he says. “I started looking outside for the camera.”

The person in the line behind the woman wanted a dozen as well, and so did other people – suddenly Mick Solomon had orders for 130 Nutella donuts for the next day. He insisted on prepayment. The donutella’s fame (a name Solomon says he came up with in a customer competition) spread from there – and not just around Melbourne.

“One of my customers sent me a message. It was a snapshot of a Facebook status saying ‘Just finished paying $16,000 for a donut’. I thought, who would do that? Sure enough, a millionaire Hong Kong woman heard about the donuts, gets on a plane, flies down here, comes in – I serve her, I don’t know who she is. There’s cars, Range Rovers and all that, me not realising what’s going on until two weeks later when I saw her picture, and I remember I served her.”

“Pauly from Fat Pizza (a TV comedy series about a Lebanese-Australian pizzeria), the actor, he came in. And then all these models started coming in, bodybuilders started coming in… the feeling was awesome, crazy, I can’t describe the feeling … I’ve got one bodybuilder, Vince Mantovani coming from Cobram, then for the next four weeks Cobram was coming down on a daily basis.”

(There must be something about Cobram, a town on Victoria’s Murray River about 3 hours’ drive north of Melbourne. Orlando Artavilla of Sugardough and Candied Bakery grew up in Cobram, and he talks about Cobram Italians coming down to Melbourne to have birthday cake at Trivelli, an Italian pasticceria in the northern suburb of Coburg. That’s another story…)

As Mick Solomon talks there’s a steady trickle of people coming out of the shop with Mick’s Donuts boxes and loading them into their cars – six, a dozen, two dozen.

“Then my daughter opened up Instagram,” he says. “I said, ‘What’s Instagram?’ She says, ‘Dad, you need it. You need Facebook. She does all the social media stuff. She’s only nine.”

“And then one day, on my phone it said, ‘This person wants to follow you’. I said, ‘Close Instagram. I’m getting followed by everybody. I don’t know what’s going on.’ I was getting nervous. She says, ‘No, that’s just Instagram dad.’”

It became a Solomon family production: his father folding boxes, his daughter printing the Mick’s Place labels, his son folding boxes too.

“Crazy,” he half whispers. “We’d run out by four o’clock. That’s the reason I started making my own, I told Carlo Capello, ‘I can’t keep up’. So I tried a few guys and I thought, that’s not going to work. I bought some machinery. Started making donuts.”

At one point people started bringing donuts back that they had bought at other stores, asking for a refund – they weren’t as good as expected.

“I rang around and found they were all over the place,” he says: other stores were passing inferior versions of the donutella off as Mick’s Donuts. “It didn’t really bother me. I’m not some entrepreneurial donut king. But I’m refunding these people’s money and I don’t know where they’ve bought them from. It was so busy in here, and we weren’t really prepared for it.

Then there were wrangles about who was first with the Nutella donut: “People saying, ‘You weren’t the original, Il Forno were the original.’ I’m not saying we were the original, but we named it the donutella.”

Nutella donuts

Hits from the shish’…. Photo: Matt Holden

Some store owners accused Mick Solomon of being greedy because he wouldn’t supply them: “I just couldn’t physically do it.”

Locals coming in for milk and cigarettes were getting caught up in the frenzy, too. “I told them, Just take your milk. Don’t worry about it. We’ll fix it up later.” Mick’s is that kind of place: he knows most of his customers, and at one point pauses to exchange a few words in Arabic with a young man.

“I was also avoiding journalists … we spoke about something and they published something else. Triple M (a local FM radio station) came down and she was awesome. An absolute legend of a person. I was inside sleeping.

“While she was here a guy from Indonesia arrived. Still got the airport duty-free bags. He says, I’ve come to see the donut guy. He says, I came from Indonesia to take a photo of this donut guy. People came from France, Hong Kong, Canada. Taking photos and also buying donuts, asking, How can we keep them fresh? I say, there’s no preservatives, they’re just donuts. I can’t freeze them.”

So why did Melbourne suddenly go nuts for Nutella donuts? “If I knew,” says Mick Solomon, “I’d do it with the next thing.”

“I’m not thinking of becoming a donut whatever, I’m just going with the flow, very steady, wherever it takes me, it takes me. But I don’t want to ruin this product, because it’s changed our lives completely.” #

A shorter version of this story first appeared in The Age’s Epicure Good Food section.


2 thoughts on “The natural history of the Nutella donut

  1. Pingback: Axil Coffee Roasters, Melbourne || the Coffee Cities Project

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s